Skip to content

5 Best Pool Covers of 2024: Top-Rated Options for a Safer, Cleaner Pool

As the saying goes, “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.” This rings especially true when it comes to pool maintenance. A good pool cover can be the difference between a safe, clean, and energy-efficient pool and one that’s plagued by debris, algae, and sky-high energy bills. You’re likely aware of the importance of a quality cover, but with so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to find the right one for your pool. That’s why we’ve done the research for you – and what we’ve found might just change the way you think about pool maintenance.

Sun2Solar Rectangle Solar Cover for In-Ground and Above-Ground Pools

Sun2Solar Rectangle Solar Cover for In-Ground and Above-Ground Pools  Get it now on Amazon.com

If you’re looking for a pool cover that can collect and retain heat while adding a touch of style to your pool area, the Sun2Solar Rectangle Solar Cover is an excellent choice, thanks to its attractive blue design with thousands of tiny bubbles.

This 16×32 feet rectangular cover is made from resin material and weighs 26 pounds, making it easy to customize with scissors to fit your unique pool shape.

As a bonus, it helps retain heat from the sun during the day and at night, reducing the need for pool heaters and saving you energy costs.

You’ll also appreciate how it prevents up to 95% of pool water evaporation and minimizes debris and leaves from entering the pool.

With its durable design, this cover can last for several seasons with proper care.

Best For: Pool owners who want to retain heat, reduce energy costs, and minimize pool maintenance, especially those with in-ground or above-ground pools.

Pros:

  • Retains heat from the sun during the day and at night, reducing the need for pool heaters and saving energy costs.
  • Prevents up to 95% of pool water evaporation and minimizes debris and leaves from entering the pool.
  • Durable and built to withstand UV rays and pool chemicals, lasting for several seasons with proper care.

Cons:

  • Some customers reported issues with the product deteriorating quickly or leaving plastic residue in the pool.
  • May need to be replaced every 1-2 years, depending on usage and maintenance.
  • Customization with scissors may be required to fit unique pool shapes.

Blue Wave BWC704 Above Ground Pool Winter Cover

Blue Wave BWC704 Above Ground Pool Winter Cover  Get it now on Amazon.com

The Blue Wave BWC704 Above Ground Pool Winter Cover is an excellent choice for pool owners seeking a reliable and long-lasting solution to protect their above-ground pool from harsh winter weather.

With its 8-year pro-rated warranty and durable polyethylene construction, this cover guarantees a snug fit with metal grommets spaced every 2 feet, a vinyl-coated cable, and a metal winch.

You’ll appreciate the woven, laminated polyethylene strands that prevent sunlight degradation and the black underside that retards algae growth.

The cover’s design confirms a proper fit with a 4-foot overlap, and it’s backed by an 8-year pro-rated warranty, so you can trust this cover to shield your pool from winter’s wrath.

Best For: Pool owners seeking a reliable and long-lasting solution to protect their above-ground pool from harsh winter weather.

Pros:

  • Durable polyethylene construction with an 8-year pro-rated warranty
  • Effective protection from winter weather and algae growth
  • Easy to install and secure with metal grommets, vinyl-coated cable, and metal winch

Cons:

  • Requires proper installation and maintenance to prevent damage
  • May not fit perfectly on all pool sizes or shapes
  • May require additional equipment, such as a submersible pump, for optimal use

Happybuy Inground Pool Safety Cover

Happybuy Inground Pool Safety Cover  Get it now on Amazon.com

Upgrading your winter pool care with a reliable safety cover like the Happybuy Inground Pool Safety Cover guarantees your pool’s protection and easy maintenance, making it an ideal choice for homeowners seeking a hassle-free winterization process.

This 16x30ft green mesh cover is designed to provide maximum strength and durability, thanks to its premium polypropylene material and triple-stitched construction.

You’ll appreciate the complete hardware kit that comes with it, making installation a breeze.

The powerful tight mesh design allows for efficient drainage while keeping leaves, snow, and debris out, ensuring a cleaner winter pool.

With its 15-year warranty and UL certification, you can trust that this cover has got you covered.

Best For: Homeowners seeking a hassle-free winterization process for their inground pools.

Pros:

  • Sturdy and durable design with premium polypropylene material and triple-stitched construction
  • Complete hardware kit for easy installation and efficient drainage
  • Reduces water evaporation and maintains cleaner winter water

Cons:

  • Some customers found the clamps to be of poor quality
  • Not sturdy enough to prevent pets from falling through
  • Some issues with installation and quality control

Pool Boy 1 Powered Pool Solar Blanket Reel

Pool Boy 1 Powered Pool Solar Blanket Reel  Get it now on Amazon.com

The Pool Boy 1 Powered Pool Solar Blanket Reel stands out due to its ability to extend and retract with the click of a button, making it an ideal choice for those who want a hassle-free pool cover experience.

This reel is designed for inground pools up to 20 feet wide and 40 feet long.

The 3-year prorated warranty provides peace of mind, and the fact that it’s made in the USA is a convenient and efficient way to manage your pool cover.

However, be aware that some users have reported quality control issues, assembly difficulties, and remote control problems.

Be cautious when attaching the solar blanket, and consider fabricating a cover to address gaps in the device.

Best For: Homeowners with inground pools up to 20 feet wide and 40 feet long who want a convenient and efficient way to manage their pool cover.

Pros:

  • Extends and retracts with the click of a button for a hassle-free pool cover experience
  • 3-year prorated warranty provides peace of mind
  • Made in the USA for a reliable and efficient product

Cons:

  • Quality control issues with cheap materials and poor design
  • Assembly difficulties and remote control problems reported by some users
  • Customer service issues, including poor phone service and unhelpful representatives

Robelle 352040R Pool Cover for Winter, Super, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools

Robelle 352040R Pool Cover for Winter, Super, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools  Get it now on Amazon.com

If you’re looking for a heavy-duty winter pool cover that can withstand harsh weather conditions, the Robelle 352040R Pool Cover is an excellent choice, designed to protect your 20 x 40 ft inground pool from winter elements.

This solid winter pool cover features a heavy-duty 8 x 8 scrim and 2.36 oz/yd2 polyethylene material, ensuring durability and reliability.

With an imperial blue topside and black underside, this cover provides a stylish and functional solution for your pool.

The 5-foot overlap makes installation a breeze, and the cover’s rectangular shape fits snugly over your pool.

With a 4.0-star rating based on over 2,800 reviews, you can trust that this cover will get the job done.

Best For: Pool owners with 20 x 40 ft inground pools looking for a heavy-duty winter pool cover to protect their pool from harsh weather conditions.

Pros:

  • Easy setup and installation with a 5-foot overlap
  • Durable and heavy-duty material with a 2.36 oz/yd2 polyethylene construction
  • Stylish and functional design with an imperial blue topside and black underside

Cons:

  • Some users reported small tears and inferior fabric quality
  • Defective products have been reported by some customers
  • Durability issues have been experienced by some users

Factors to Consider When Choosing Pool Covers

When choosing a pool cover, you’ll want to think about several key factors to guarantee you get the right one for your pool.

You’ll need to ponder the shape of your pool, the durability of the material, and the size of the cover to verify a proper fit.

Additionally, you’ll want to weigh the weight and portability of the cover, as well as the reputation of the brand you’re buying from.

Pool Shape Considerations

Considering your pool’s unique shape is essential in finding the perfect cover, as a custom-fit is necessary to prevent damage and guarantee a secure fit.

You’ll find rectangular pool covers in various sizes, such as 16×32 feet and 20×40 feet, to accommodate different pool dimensions.

However, if you have an L-shaped or kidney-shaped pool, you’ll need a customizable cover that can be trimmed to fit using scissors or other cutting tools.

When measuring your pool for a cover, don’t forget to include the size of any steps or ledges, ensuring the cover is large enough to accommodate these features.

A 4-foot overlap is also essential to prevent wind from getting under the cover, making it suitable for both rectangular and irregularly shaped pools.

By considering your pool’s shape, you’ll be able to find a cover that fits perfectly, preventing damage and ensuring a safe and clean pool.

Material Durability Matters

You’ll want your pool cover to withstand harsh weather conditions and last for years to come, so it’s essential to choose a material that’s durable and resistant to degradation.

A high-quality material will guarantee your cover remains effective and efficient, even under extreme temperatures, intense sunlight, and harsh chemicals.

When evaluating materials, look for those with high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or polyethylene (PE) construction.

These materials are known for their exceptional strength, UV resistance, and ability to withstand harsh pool chemicals.

You should also consider the material’s thickness, measured in mils (1 mil = 0.001 inch).

A thicker material typically indicates greater durability and longer lifespan.

Additionally, consider the material’s coating and treatment.

A good quality coating will provide an extra layer of protection against the elements and prevent degradation.

Some materials may also be treated with UV inhibitors or other additives to enhance their durability.

Size Accurately for Fit

Accurately sizing your pool cover is essential, as a poor fit can compromise safety and efficiency, so take the time to measure your pool meticulously.

To guarantee a proper fit, measure your pool’s length, width, and any obstructions like steps or ledges. Consider a cover with a 3- to 5-foot overlap to account for these irregularities.

When sizing your pool cover, consider the pool’s shape, as rectangular or irregularly shaped pools may require custom-fit covers or additional installation hardware.

Use a tape measure to record the pool’s dimensions in multiple locations, as pool shapes and sizes can vary.

Consult the manufacturer’s sizing chart to verify an accurate fit. For above-ground pools, measure from the outside edge of the pool wall to confirm the cover is large enough to drape over the sides and fit securely.

To prevent wind, water, or debris from getting under the cover, confirm the cover is large enough to cover the entire pool surface and extends at least 12 inches beyond the pool’s edge.

Weight and Portability

When it comes to choosing the right pool cover, you’ll want to think about how you’ll be handling and storing it, as a lightweight and portable cover can make a big difference in your overall experience.

You’ll likely need to remove and reinstall the cover regularly, so prioritize the weight and portability of your chosen cover. A lighter cover will be easier to handle, reducing the strain on your back and making the process less exhausting.

Additionally, a portable cover will allow you to easily store it when not in use, keeping it out of the way and protected from the elements.

Look for covers made from lightweight materials, such as polyethylene or polyester, which are often more portable than heavier options like vinyl.

You should also bear in mind the foldability of the cover, as this will impact how easily you can store it. A cover that can be easily folded and stored will take up less space and be less of a hassle to manage.

Brand Reputation Counts

By investing in a pool cover from a reputable brand, you can rest assured that you’re getting a high-quality product that will provide a safe and secure pool environment.

A brand’s reputation is built on its history of producing reliable and effective pool covers, which gives you peace of mind when making a purchase. Look for brands with a strong reputation, as they often have a track record of positive customer reviews, ratings, and testimonials.

This can be a great way to inform your purchasing decision and avoid potential issues with the pool cover. Additionally, well-established brands are more likely to invest in research and development, resulting in innovative and improved pool cover designs, materials, and features.

Warranty and Support

A thorough warranty and support system can provide peace of mind and protection for your investment in a pool cover.

When evaluating warranty and support, consider the length of the warranty, the scope of coverage, and the quality of customer service, including response times, knowledge, and helpfulness.

Look for manufacturers that provide clear warranty terms, easy claims processing, and dedicated support teams to facilitate timely resolutions to any issues that may arise.

Additionally, consider the availability of online resources, such as FAQs, user manuals, and tutorial videos, which can provide valuable guidance and troubleshooting assistance.

A robust warranty and support system can also indicate a manufacturer’s confidence in their product’s quality and performance, giving you greater confidence in your purchase decision.

Ease of Installation

As you consider the warranty and support offered by a pool cover manufacturer, it’s equally important to think about the installation process, as a hassle-free experience can make all the difference in getting your pool up and running quickly and safely.

A pool cover that’s easy to install can save you time and effort, guaranteeing a proper fit that prevents accidents and prolongs the cover’s lifespan.

When choosing a pool cover, look for one with a simple and tool-free installation process, such as a ‘drill and tamp’ style anchoring system.

Adjustable ropes or straps can also facilitate a secure and customized fit, regardless of your pool’s shape or size.

Some pool covers even come with a complete hardware kit, including anchors, springs, and installation tools, to facilitate a smooth and stress-free installation process.

Remember to follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions carefully to confirm a successful and safe installation, and to prevent voiding the warranty.

Safety Features Prioritized

When it comes to choosing a pool cover, prioritizing safety features is essential, and you must consider factors that prevent accidents, reduce risks, and provide a secure pool environment. You want to confirm that your pool cover is designed with safety in mind, protecting people and pets from potential hazards.

Look for pool covers with features like automatic locking systems, which prevent accidental removal or shifting of the cover. A cover that’s designed with a tight fit and secure anchoring system will reduce the risk of entrapment or slipping. Additionally, consider pool covers made from durable, heavy-duty materials that can withstand various weather conditions and heavy use.

Another key factor is the cover’s ability to prevent debris and contaminants from entering the pool. A cover with a tight weave or mesh will keep dirt, leaves, and other debris out, reducing the risk of contamination and making maintenance easier. By prioritizing safety features, you can enjoy a safer, cleaner, and more enjoyable pool experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Use a Pool Cover as a Substitute for Pool Fencing?

You’re wondering if a pool cover can replace pool fencing, but it’s not a suitable substitute. Pool covers are designed for safety and cleanliness, not as a barrier to prevent access, so you’ll still need fencing to protect safety around your pool.

Do Pool Covers Really Help Reduce Pool Heating Costs?

You’re trying to peel back the layers of pool maintenance costs, and we’re here to help! Think of your pool as a warm hug – you want to keep it cozy, right? Using a pool cover can be like wrapping your pool in a snug blanket, reducing heat loss and saving you around 30% on heating costs.

Are Automatic Pool Covers Worth the Extra Cost?

You’re wondering if automatic pool covers are worth the extra cost. Honestly, they’re a game-changer for convenience and safety, but you’ll need to weigh their higher upfront cost against long-term savings and benefits.

Can I Install a Pool Cover Myself or Do I Need a Professional?

You’re wondering if you can install a pool cover yourself or need a pro? While it’s possible to DIY, improperly installed covers can void warranties, so consider hiring a professional for a stress-free, correct installation.

How Often Should I Clean and Maintain My Pool Cover?

You’re finally taking care of that pool cover, huh? Don’t worry, it’s not like it’s going to start judging you for neglecting it (although, let’s be real, it probably is). Clean it every 1-2 months, and perform a deep clean every 6-12 months.

Conclusion

You’ve made it to the end of our review of the 5 best pool covers of 2024!

With these top-rated options, you’re one step closer to a safer, cleaner pool.

Did you know that using a pool cover can reduce energy costs by up to 70%?

By investing in a high-quality pool cover, you’ll not only save money but also extend the lifespan of your pool.

Choose the right cover for your in-ground or above-ground pool and enjoy a hassle-free swimming experience.